After the marriage of his brother, Samuel is wondering who will be next. Will his younger brother marry one of the many women who follow on his every word, or will his elder brother bring a wife home and save him the chore of cooking every few days. Then a chance encounter puts him back in touch with his only love. Well he would have loved her if she ever noticed he even existed.

But that was a long time ago, and Samuel has made sure he kept well away from Miriam. The woman was nothing but heartache and trouble.

Things go from bad to worse, did he lose his mind or did he really steal a kiss? Being brought up in front of the Bishop could end his time with the Amish. How could things go so wrong?

Can Samuel save his reputation and find love or will history repeat itself and leave him humiliated and not wanting to try again?